Showing posts with label protracted displacement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label protracted displacement. Show all posts

Friday, 28 February 2020

Workshop: Navigating from education to employment in crisis and uncertainty

Zoe Jordan writes:

Young people’s position in the labour market is increasingly precarious and uncertainty is an ever-present dimension for young people living in protracted displacement and other crisis settings. Over the last decade, much progress has been made in developing frameworks to provide education in crisis. However, there is currently limited research examining the relationship between education and employment prospects in such contexts.

As part of the ESRC/GCRF and IDRC funded research programme “From education to employment. Trajectories for young people in Lebanon and Jordan in the context of protracted displacement”, CENDEP, in collaboration with the Centre for Lebanese Studies (CLS), is hosting an international workshop responding to the need for greater insight into young people’s trajectories from education to employment in crisis settings from 28 – 29 April 2020. Preliminary findings from the research programme will be presented, and we invite researchers and policy makers working in other contexts of uncertainty to join us to share insights, analytical approaches, and empirical realities.

We will be questioning education and employment strategies among young people and their families in the context of crisis; intersectionality and its workings in young people’s trajectories, focusing particularly on legal status, gender, disability, class and other social positions; the relevance of education for employment in the context of protracted displacement; and how young people are categorized and conceptualised, and its implications for policy and practice.

Paper presentations (15 – 20 minutes) and interventions for a roundtable discussion (5 minutes) are invited. Please send short abstracts (up to 200 words) indicating which format you would like to present, to Zoe Jordan (zjordan@brookes.ac.uk) by 17 March 2020.

Wednesday, 6 November 2019

Work in Progress: Exceptional and futureless humanitarian education in Lebanon

Maha Shuayb and Cathrine Brun write about their Work in Progress seminar this Thursday, entitled Exceptional and futureless humanitarian education in Lebanon: Prospects for shifting the lens. The seminar is from 16.30 to 18.00 on Thursday, 7 November in JHB307.

In this talk, we aim to unpack and analyse the potentials and shortcomings of a humanitarian framework for educational responses in protracted displacement. Most literature on this topic tends to examine humanitarianism and education separately and few studies have analysed the effect of the humanitarian model on the education provisions and policies and most importantly on the outcomes. Humanitarianism is concerned with the immediate while education is a future oriented-activity. Hence the interrelation between the two might appear an oxymoron. At the same time, calls to shift the humanitarian discourse from relief and survival to development have given strong grounds to include education as part of the humanitarian response in a situation of crisis. Yet there is a lack of clarity concerning the concept of development which the education provisions rest on. In the talk we will unpack the concept of education in emergency and its effect on students’ schooling outcomes. The study focuses on Lebanon as a case to analyse the potentials and limitations of this model. To do so, the study analyses the educational policies and interventions Lebanon introduced in the last seven years since the outbreak of the Syrian crisis and examine their impact on the education outcomes of Syrian children. In conclusion, we reflect on some of the potential outcomes of the current model and introduces some alternatives to the current education system for refugees. 

Maha Shuayb is the director of the Centre for Lebanese Studies (CLS). Maha has a PhD in education from the University of Cambridge. She also teaches part-time at the Lebanese American University. She is currently a visiting fellow at the University of Cambridge. Maha’s research focuses on the sociology and politics of education particularly equity and equality in education and the implications of the politicization of education particularly on marginalized groups. Over the past eight years, Maha has been occupied with the education response to the Syrian Refugee crisis in Lebanon. She has headed a number of research studies looking at access and quality of education for refugees and the bottlenecks. A recent studies include a comparative longitudinal study between Lebanon, Turkey, Germany and Australia which examines the impact of status on education provisions for refugees in the four countries. 

Professor Cathrine Brun is a human geographer and Director of the Centre for Development and Emergency Practice (CENDEP), the School of Architecture at Oxford Brookes University, UK. Her research-interests concern forced migration and conflict, housing and home; theory, ethics and practice of humanitarianism. Working closely with local and national organisations in places like Georgia, Sri Lanka, Malawi and Lebanon, her approach to research is qualitative, ethnographic and using action research as a way of co-producing knowledge. Some recent publications include “Living with shifting borders: peripheralisation and the production of invisibility” (2017, Geopolitics); “Mobilising home for long term displacement: a reflection on the durable solutions” (with Anita H. Fábos, 2017, Journal of Human Rights Practice,); “Homemaking in limbo? A conceptual framework” (with Anita H. Fàbos, Refuge, 2015) and “There is no Future in Humanitarianism” (History and Anthropology, 2015).

Maha, the CLS and Cathrine and CENDEP currently collaborate on an ESRC and IDRC funded research programme on From Education to Employment: young people’s trajectories in the context of protracted displacement in Lebanon and Jordan.

Sunday, 3 February 2019

Mobilising home for protracted displacement

This week's Work in Progress seminar will be given by Anita H. Fábos, Department of International Development, Community, and Environment, Clark University and Cathrine Brun, CENDEP, Oxford Brookes University. They explain the topic:
 
Despite the contemporary rise of long-term refugee displacement, policies in place to manage it are based on remarkably static notions of home. In our talk, we use a feminist analysis of ‘home’ to critique binary policies of “home” and “not-home.” Instead, we propose that refugees themselves link different temporal and spatial dimentions of home into fluid constellations of home, and maintain these constellations through their mobile homekeeping practices. The multi-dimensional homes that refugees make through their daily house-keeping activities, networking and memory-work, and navigation through the international humanitarian system are recognizable as the shared human experience of home and a basis for improved and inclusive policies.

The seminar will be at 17.00 in the Abercrombie Building, Headington Campus, Third Floor, Stdent Hub, White Space. All welcome. See here for details of all the seminars.

Wednesday, 28 February 2018

Imagining Refugia: thinking beyond the current migration impasse - work in progress seminar


Nicholas Van Hear writes:
The UN is currently steering the international community towards global ‘compacts’ on migration and refugees, due to be agreed by the end of 2018.  While the aims of the compacts are worthy, many lack confidence that they hold promise of real progress, nor that the three traditional ‘durable solutions’ (local integration, resettlement and return) can address the challenge on the scale needed – addressing the often ‘protracted displacement’ of some 65 million people worldwide.  
This contribution takes as a starting point recent proposals that depart from the usual three ‘durable solutions’ and the current international migration architecture, and that think about alternatives.  One set of proposals explores the idea of new nations or polities for refugees and migrants – suggestions that have been dismissed as fantasies by many commentators.  But perhaps such seemingly outlandish proposals should not be rejected out of hand.  The presentation will explore the possibility not of a new ‘refugee nation’ on an island or other bounded territory, but rather a new kind of transnational polity – Refugia.  We envisage this as a linked set of territories and spaces connecting refugee and other migrant communities that would be governed by refugees and migrants themselves.  The key feature of Refugia is that its different parts are connected, with mobility between them, and that the whole is greater than the sum of the parts.

It will be suggested that such a transnational polity is already imperfectly prefigured in many of the transnational practices that refugees and migrants deploy and the environments in which they find themselves today -- in both the ‘global south’ and the ‘global north’.  Camps and communities in countries neighbouring conflicts, neighbourhoods in global cities, transnational political practices and money transfers, emergent communities in disparate locations en route: all are fragments that taken separately do not seem to promise much. But cumulatively they could add up to Refugia, imperfectly prefigured. Consolidating them into a common polity might prove to be a way out of the current impasse.
The seminar is on Thursday 1 March, 16.30-18.00, in the Student Hub, White Space, on the 3rd floor of the Abercrombie building. All welcome. For the whole seminar series programme, check: http://cendep.blogspot.co.uk/2018/01/work-in-progress-seminars-all-welcome.html.

The presentation will develop ideas set out in Cohen and Van Hear 2017 ‘Visions of Refugia: territorial and transnational solutions to mass displacement‘, in Planning Theory & Practice. 

Monday, 27 November 2017

The case for an ethics of care in humanitarianism’s inbetween spaces


Cathrine Brun writes:

More and more of today’s crises are in non-traditional humanitarian settings where the relations between relief and development are blurred; where current humanitarian principles, guidelines and manuals may not be helpful for the humanitarian workers present on the ground. 

Increasingly, humanitarians engage in situations that are less distinguished by urgency, but where, nevertheless, the humanitarian community plays a crucial role. One clear example is long-term displacement. In 2015, UNHCR identified 26 years as the average duration of the 32 protracted refugee situations in which they worked. In these inbetween spaces where needs are between relief and development, humanitarians continue to operate with a humanitarian logic distinguished by emergency, urgency and out of the ordinary measures that to a large degree concerns saving people’s lives rather than development. The challenges humanitarian workers face, however, are far beyond the humanitarian mandate, its ethical register, principles, laws and guidelines. 

In long term displacement, when needs may be closer to development than to relief, the host state may not approve of a development strategy for refugees. There is often a political interest to focus on return or resettlement. A shift in policy towards local integration and consequently more long term presence of the refugees is not an acceptable strategy at the national political level. In these settings, relief and humanitarian practice is often the only accepted way for the international community to assist. But both refugees and humanitarian workers feel hugely constrained by this situation where they are restricted from developing lives. In their day-to-day practice, humanitarian workers try their best to create a future for people they work with and with whom they and their organisations often establish long-term relationships due to the duration of displacement and of the humanitarian operation.[i]

In my current research, I explore how the current ethical register of humanitarianism can be expanded in ways that allow a more relevant humanitarian practice in long term refugee situations. The most dominant stance in humanitarianism today is a so-called ‘principled approach’ where the humanitarian principles (of which the first four are humanity, neutrality, impartiality and independence) are guiding the work and decision-making of an organisation. The principles have become a common vocabulary for people working in the system and are often the main moral compass for humanitarian actors. However, to put it simply, the principles are largely about how to not become part of the local context in which humanitarians work. Detachment becomes a way to stay neutral, impartial and independent. But in long term refugee situations where humanitarians have a long-term presence, this detachment becomes more problematic. Many humanitarian workers that we have interviewed call for more focus on understanding the multiple and complex relations that they are part of when assisting in long term crises. For such contexts, the humanitarian principles are less useful because they place less emphasis on the face-to-face encounters that humanitarian workers are always involved in: the particular day-to-day interactions with refugees and other actors. With the humanitarian inbetween spaces in mind, I would like to suggest that current humanitarian ethics can open up for a more relational approach and an ethics of care could help us here. 

Ethics of care has been largely dismissed or avoided in humanitarianism. In long term displacement, however, an ethics of care helps to capture better than the traditional humanitarian principles what humanitarian workers do in the field. Caring “may be said to include everything we do directly to help others to meet their basic needs, develop or sustain their basic capabilities, and alleviate or avoid pain or suffering, in an attentive, responsive and respectful manner.”[ii] 

Care ethics concerns caring in four phases[iii]: Caring about is the recognition that care is necessary, identifying a need; caring for is to take care of and assumes some responsibility for the need; care-giving is the direct meeting of needs for care; and, care-receiving recognizes that the subject of care will respond to the care she or he receives. 

Based on the reflections above, I would suggest that an ethics of care can help humanitarianism become more relevant because it is practice-based, it is an ethics developed through what humanitarian workers do in their interaction with others. An ethics of care opens up for a more nuanced understanding of the multiple and often complex relations involved in humanitarian practice. With an ethics of care, we bring in contextualisation to enable attentiveness towards localised practices of care. While humanitarianism is oriented towards solving an urgent need in the present, an ethics of care opens up for a more future oriented approach where assistance is always attached to specific individuals, their biographies and the possible development of their future.









[i] Brun, C. 2016. There is no future in humanitarianism: Emergency, temporality and protracted displacement. History and Anthropology 27(4): 393–410.
[ii] Engster 2015: 55, original emphasis
[iii] Tronto, J. 1993. Moral Boundaries. A political argument for an ethic of care. London: Routledge.



Monday, 30 October 2017

Internal displacement and local integration in Ukraine


Cathrine Brun writes:

On 19 and 20 October I was invited by the Council of Europe to talk at their National Forum organised in cooperation with the Ministry for Temporarily Occupied Territories and Internally Displaced Persons of Ukraine and with the support of the Embassy of Japan in Ukraine. The Forum was titled “Three Years of Displacement:
Challenges and Good Practices of IDP integration” and was part of a Council of Europe project on “Strengthening the Human Rights Protection of Internally Displaced Persons in Ukraine”. Displacement is a relatively new situation in Ukraine and, at the moment, there are believed to be between 1.6 and 1.8 million internally displaced (IDPs), forced to move since the complex conflict started in March 2014. 

Cathrine Brun (right) in Kyiv
More than 100 delegates participated in the forum with representatives from the internally displaced, from civil society, local and national governments and international humanitarian organisations. The meeting was part of a process to draft a new state strategy for durable solutions for the IDPs. Durable solutions are problematic in many contexts and are often out of reach for displaced populations (see Brun and Fàbos 2017, CENDEP blog by Richard Carver). However, Ukraine stands out as a special case because, already after three years, there is emphasis on local integration rather than return as the preferred solution that has often been the norm. 

We cannot assume that all IDPs in Ukraine prefer integration over return. Additionally, there is still much to be done to secure people’s rights to keep connections to the places they fled from and their right to move on from where they first arrived as displaced. The new national strategy must make sure that these rights are being accessed. At the same time, the relatively early emphasis on integration enables a more long-term and better prospect for people at the places where they are displaced. 

When I was first invited to the Forum, I was asked to talk about integration of IDPs. However, in my work with local integration processes for IDPs, I have come to understand integration as what IDPs and their hosts do, I thus changed the title to talk about integration by IDPs.
In this context, we can understand integration as both an end-point and a process. As an end-point, integration can be said to be when the IDPs have become full members of the societies that they have moved to, but there are many discussions around when displacement ends. Often, these discussions are related to when displaced are no longer in need of assistance as a result of their displacement. Some of the legal measures that are currently being discussed in the Council of Europe project are crucial to put in place for integration to happen. IDPs must be ensured the same rights as their co-nationals, but at the moment this is not always happening. 

Integration can also be seen as a process, and can be defined as ‘collective change’: that is the changes that take place in a society where IDPs and hosts meet and interact (Kuhlman 1994). With integration as a process, we can focus on how the host communities are actively involved in integration processes and assistance can be helpful in assisting interaction that already exists between IDPs and hosts. Rather than a purely legal perspective or an emphasis on the IDP-category as a status, a focus on integration as collective change, enables a needs-based approach to assistance: where the most vulnerable groups among both hosts and IDPs get access to assistance. 

Finally, when dealing with local integration, I want to add a note of caution. After three years of displacement in Ukraine, the IDP category is already well established. From my brief encounter with the situation in the country, it seems to be a category that is taken for granted and used to separate the displaced from their hosts in essential ways, such as access to rights. If the situation of displacement becomes protracted, if the local integration process takes a long time, and if the government continues to treat the people who were displaced and who are placed in the IDP category as separate from the non-displaced, there is a danger that the IDP category moves from being a humanitarian category established to assist people in need of relief due to their displacement to a social category – an underclass or marginalised group that does not enjoy full membership in the society, which we have seen in other contexts (Brun et al. 2017). 
Local integration will continue to happen in places where IDPs and hosts co-exist, but without full membership, recognition and participation in the local communities where they live, displacement may not come to an end.


References


Brun, C. and A.H. Fàbos. 2017. Mobilising home for long term displacement: a reflection on the durable solutions. Journal of Human Rights Practice, https://doi.org/10.1093/jhuman/hux021

Brun, C., A.H. Fàbos, O. El Abed. 2017. Abject citizenship: when categories of displacement collide with categories if citizenship. Norwegian Journal of Geography 71(4): 220–232

Carver, R. 2017. An end to refugee protection? CENDEP blog 09.10.17, http://cendep.blogspot.co.uk/2017/10/an-end-to-refugee-protection.html

Kuhlman, T. 1994. Asylum or Aid? The Economic Integration of Ethiopian and Eritrean Refugees in the Sudan. Research Series 2/1994, African Studies Centre, Leiden.

Monday, 9 October 2017

An end to refugee protection?


Richard Carver writes:

Two CENDEP scholars have contributed to a symposium in the Journal of Human Rights Practice looking at new challenges posed by the historically high level of forced migration in the world today. I co-edited the symposium, with Kirsten McConnachie from the University of Warwick and Martin Jones from the University of York, as well as writing an article on the role of national human rights institutions in refugee protection. CENDEP director Cathrine Brun, with Anita Fábos of Clark University, contributed a piece on new approaches to “durable solutions” for refugees and internally displaced persons.

The deliberately provocative title of the collection is “The end of refugee protection?” This is probably an instance of Betteridge’s law of headlines (which states that any headline that ends in a question mark can be answered by the word “No”). However, the implication is that the existing international refugee regime has been inadequate in the face of the multiple crises of the past few years. The common theme is not so much that refugee protection is at an end, as that there is a need to adopt innovative solutions. Cathrine and Anita, for example, point out the importance of bottom-up approaches based on refugees’ own needs and initiatives in a situation where protracted displacement has become the new normal.

It might seem unremarkable that a human rights journal should host a discussion on refugees, yet the sad reality is that the worlds of human rights and refugee protection are often far apart. The international legal regimes governing human rights and refugees were adopted at the same time (late 1940s and early 1950s), in response to the same set of events – the Second World War, Holocaust and subsequent refugee crisis. Yet the two sets of norms use completely different language and conceptual frameworks. The third legal framework updated at the same time, international humanitarian law (IHL), is different again. This would be all well and good if the aim were to generate work for international lawyers, but it can lead to crucial misunderstandings and efforts that are at cross-purposes. To give one simple example, the word “protection,” contained in the title of our feature, has quite distinct meanings in human rights, refugee law, and IHL.

One practical consequence of this has been that the communities of practice of human rights and refugee advocacy have often been quite distinct and separate. (There are, of course, important exceptions, such as Amnesty International, a human rights organization that has long worked on behalf of refugees.) My article in this symposium, in common with several others, argues for a new convergence between human rights and refugee protection.

Joint team from Greek and Macedonian Ombudsmen visit refugee border camp
The example I explore is a rare piece of good news to emerge from the European “refugee crisis.” National human rights institutions (NHRIs) – that is official human rights commissions or ombudsmen – have not historically done much work on refugees. This is because they are usually complaints-driven. Refugees tend not to be aware of the existence of such bodies or how to file complaints with them. In recent years, however, many European NHRIs have taken on a role in inspecting places of detention. This is usually because of a mandate given to them under the snappily titled Optional Protocol to the United Nations Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment – understandably referred to by its acronym, OPCAT.

The OPCAT requires that these “national preventive mechanisms” have legal powers to carry out visits to places of detention or imprisonment in order to inspect conditions and prevent torture or other ill-treatment. Among the places to be visited are immigration detention centres (and often, by extension, other migrant encampments, even if these are not formally places of detention). In this role, NHRIs, especially in southern Europe, have encountered refugees directly. The visiting bodies in countries such as Greece, Macedonia, Serbia, and Croatia have played an important role, not only in inspecting the conditions in which refugees are housed, but also in giving them advice and conducting more general advocacy on their behalf. International coordination between the inspection bodies has been aimed at creating a common response and making sure that refugees do not fall between the cracks of different national protection systems.

Monday, 18 September 2017

A visit to Syrian refugee settlements in Lebanon


Abeer Al-Mutawakel (DEP 2016-17) writes:

In May 2017, I went on my first field trip with Oxford Brookes University to Lebanon. The field trip aimed to study the impact of displacement on Lebanon, particularly on the city of Saida and its surroundings, given the existing Palestinian and Syrian refugees in the country. Field trips are part of CENDEP’s program offered to students, which complement the academic side of research, and offer a practical side. During our stay in Saida we visited multiple Syrian refugee shelters and conducted many interviews. Visiting a shelter, and getting a chance to talk with people was a completely different experience compared to reading about it. Talking with Syrian refugees helped me to connect with them, feel their suffering, and learn about their journeys and the changes in their lives before and during the war in Syria. It made me feel the impact of a conflict in reality, and not just on paper.
Shheem informal camp
The first camp we visited was in Shheem. The camp has 380 people in it according to the Lebanese owner of the land who allowed them to stay there for free. They came from the different parts of Syria. They built their own shelters using donated materials. They were simple rooms, but Syrian women proudly referred to them as ‘my house’ when talking about them.

We all gathered in one place with the women in the camp for a group discussion. They welcomed us, offering us tea although we knew that they are short of basic commodities. During our gathering, the first noticeable thing was the care given to their looks, having make up on and nice outfits. It showed that women care about their appearance and dignity despite their hard living conditions.
Group discussion with women at Shheem camp
The second noticeable thing is the pregnancy rate among young women. Most young women in that camp were pregnant and had babies and toddlers at the same time. This concerned me about the opportunities for the coming generation.

During our group conversation, the Syrian women were open to discuss their situation, how their husbands are finding it hard to find jobs, and if they do, they are not paid fairly. They expressed their dissatisfaction about the relevance of aid being received both in terms of services (such as teaching them how to wash their hands or babies, which they found insulting) or in-kind contributions (such as clothes that do not fit their kids). This reflects the importance of understanding the context and conducting needs assessment, which was always emphasised on DEP students during multiple modules in its program.

Inside a house at Shheem camp
 

After our group discussion, I had a chance to have a side conversation with one of the refugee women who was one of the first comers to Shheem camp. She has been living there for six years. She has two girls and two boys. She invited me to her house; I was amazed how tidy and organised her house is, how she decorated the fridge and TV to make it feel like home for them. Although these are simple things, they made me feel her resilience and adaptability. Before leaving her house, she whispered to me excitedly that she has been offered to travel with her family to a foreign country, but did not know where yet. After six years in Shheem camp, she hopes that her and her family’s life will change. 

Pepsi shelter in Saida
We visited another shelter in Saida known as Pepsi. It was an old abandoned factory, which had three upper levels consisting of multiple apartments and two separated basements consisting of over 40 rooms for storage which were now all rented to Syrian refugees. There were 130 to 150 families living in this shelter with at least 800 kids. The interesting thing about this shelter is that all the refugees living in it are from the same town in Syria. When the war first started, families sent away youth between the age of 14-26 to avoid them being recruited by fighting groups, and youth later started calling for their families to come and join them. 

The basement rooms being rented in this shelter were not in proper liveable condition. Rooms looked like a garage and most of them did not have windows and therefore no air or sunlight. The basement was damp and dark.
Basement of Pepsi shelter
Some rooms would house a family of seven, and some even more (one of the rooms I visited was split into two, having the first wife and her five daughters in one half, and the other wife with her five kids in the other). Most rooms have a small kitchen built within the room and they all have shared toilets except for few. These conditions encourage the spread of diseases and impacts the growth of children living there. Some rooms are under the main road, and are at risk of having their ceiling collapse as happened with one of the rooms we visited. On top of these poor conditions, Syrian refugees pay rent of around $100 - $160 per room depending on the size. The apartments being rented in upper levels were much better and more expensive ($350/month).

Room in Pepsi shelter basement
A family we interviewed living in an apartment said that if they had a chance to live in the basement they would go for it, but they came late and there was no room for them, so they have to pay the higher rent. They can rent a better apartment outside the shelter with the same amount, but they’d rather stay with their ‘community’. Moreover, most kids living in shelters are not going to school. Parents worry about getting the basic needs such as food, shelter and health. In Pepsi shelter only a third of the children go to school and numbers keep dropping down because kids are expected to help in supporting their families.
Children pose for the camera in Pepsi shelter basement

Tuesday, 12 September 2017

Exploring refugee hosting in Jordan

After a long summer hiatus, the CENDEP blog is resuming with the new semester just a couple of weeks away. First, PhD student Zoe Jordan is embarking on her fieldwork in Jordan:

I’ve recently arrived in Jordan to begin fieldwork for my PhD research, looking at hosting practices for refugees in urban Amman, and how humanitarian assistance influences these relationships during situations of long-term displacement.
Jordan has received one of the highest numbers of refugees from the on-going Syrian conflict. According to UNHCR, Jordan is the second largest host of refugees per capita in the world. In addition to the Syrian refugee population, Jordan also hosts refugees from Palestine, Iraq, Sudan, Somalia, and Yemen, as well as smaller populations from many other countries. While refugees continue to arrive in Jordan many people are in long-term displacement situations, having been in Jordan for years. These features make Jordan an interesting context in which to understand the changing nature of relationships between refugees and their hosts as displacement becomes increasingly protracted. Given the strength of familial and tribal ties between Jordan and its Arab neighbours, it is also interesting to explore potential differences in hosting arrangements between refugees and hosts from different national groups.
While media attention and much of the humanitarian response remains focused on the large refugee camps of Zaatari and Azraq, up to ninety per cent of refugees live outside of camps. The situation for many families in Amman is critical – up to ninety-three percent of Syrian refugees outside of camps live in extreme poverty, and there is only limited assistance available for non-Syrian refugees. The presence of refugees in urban areas and the importance of their host families has been recognised by the Jordanian authorities and humanitarian actors. Important lessons on how to provide humanitarian assistance in urban settings are emerging from Jordan, and there is an increasing awareness of the vital role of hosts in supporting refugee families. Despite this recognition, there is little understanding of the personal relationships and household-level dynamics between refugees and their hosts.
Jordan is not a party to the 1951 UN Convention on Refugees, nor its 1967 Protocol. Many Jordanians are proud of their reputation for hospitality, and the influence of Arabic and Islamic traditions of hospitality are evident in day-to-day and policy discourse regarding refugees in Jordan. At the everyday level, this hospitality can be seen in the relations between refugees and their hosts. Host families may provide material, financial, or social and emotional support for refugees, and often continue this support well past the moment of crisis, facilitating refugees to integrate with the host community, and to become independent while in displacement. For many, “host family” conjures an image of a refugee family and a host family sharing a space, acting a household, who identify themselves to be in a hosting relationship. This understanding does not capture the full range of supportive relationships between hosts and refugees in Jordan, and does not respond to the shifting dynamics of refugee-host relations as displacement becomes protracted. A broader perspective on hosting practices allows us to consider the range of social relations which may be engaged in by refugees and hosts, and the potential for strategies to overlap.
Hosting relationships are not easily characterizable nor perceived in the same way by all participants. Existing research has focused on community level relations, but seems to be little in-depth research into the different types of relationship between hosts and refugees, nor the experience of being a hosted or of hosting a displaced family. Situating my research in Jordan allows me to understand how hosting practices are maintained and developed in contexts of protracted displacement, and provides an opportunity to explore local traditions and practices of humanitarian assistance and hospitality and their impact on refugee hosting practices.
In my first few weeks in Amman, I will be meeting with staff from international organisations and local NGOs, asking them to share their knowledge on the current state of humanitarian engagement with urban refugees and host families in situations of protracted displacement in Amman, and to provide their feedback on my research design. In the following months, I will continue working with humanitarian organisations and community centres to speak to refugees and hosts about their current living arrangements, their experiences of living in Amman, and their interaction with humanitarian actors. From this, I hope to be able to identify common patterns and experiences in different people’s hosting arrangements, as well as beginning to explore the differences between people’s experiences, and some of the reasons behind this.