Showing posts with label NHRIs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label NHRIs. Show all posts

Monday, 4 December 2017

The only way is ethics: accountability in human rights investigations


Richard Carver writes:
Last week Cathrine Brun questioned whether the ethical signposts that guide modern humanitarianism are adequate for many of the new challenges faced. This week, I return to the topic of ethics, but at a much more elementary level. For non-practitioners it is probably baffling that human rights work has no agreed ethical code to guide those who are working in the sector. Of course, it could be argued that the whole body of human rights is itself an ethical code, but that argument seems dangerous. The fact that human rights practitioners claim to uphold human rights – they would, wouldn’t they? – does not exempt them from independent ethical scrutiny and accountability.
When I first started working as a human rights researcher in the 1980s, I was surprised that there was apparently no agreed code of conduct for people doing my job. My employer, Amnesty International, had very clear rules on one or two issues, such as confidentiality of information collected in the course of our work, but little beyond that. I had previously worked as a journalist and, as a member of the National Union of Journalists, I had committed to be bound by the union’s code of conduct. As a human rights investigator, I suppose I continued to follow the same precepts but nothing was clearly spelt out.

This large gap was drawn to my attention once again last year, when I conducted a training workshop for national human rights institutions (NHRIs) on how to conduct investigations. Participants asked what ethical standards should guide their work and I had to give the honest answer that there was no single agreed code for human rights investigators (and indeed that most NHRIs had no code of conduct at all). An interesting discussion followed and I concluded that future training sessions needed to consider the main ethical principles guiding human rights research.
A year later I found myself in a yurt, half way up a mountain in Kazakhstan, delivering another training session on behalf of the United Nations Development Programme, to investigators from Central Asian national human rights institutions. This time I was better prepared. In the absence of any coherent template of a code of conduct, I looked at a number of other professions that are guided by codes of conduct and where there might be overlaps with the issues posed in human rights investigations.

The first and obvious port of call was the legal profession. Many NHRI investigators – perhaps a majority – are lawyers. They will be regulated by national accreditation bodies that usually require, among other things:

·       Adherence to the principle of legality and the obligation of lawyers to uphold the rule of law at all times;

·       Protection of the best interests of the client (as far as consistent with the principle of legality);

·       Protection of lawyer-client confidentiality.
Medical practitioners are another group with well-known ethical obligations. Physicians swear the Hippocratic Oath, but this is probably of little relevance, except when the human rights investigator is herself a medical practitioner. However, another principle of medical ethics, “Do No Harm,” may be highly relevant. This is not, as is often supposed, part of the Hippocratic Oath, but is nevertheless a fundamental ethical requirement. Doctors may not embark on reckless treatment that may harm a patient. This is a principle that has been adopted by humanitarian practitioners, since Mary Anderson’s 1999 book of the same name. Perhaps human rights researchers also need to consider its relevance.

Academic researchers have constructed a rather complex edifice of ethical rules. The underlying principles here are autonomy, beneficence, and justice. These refer respectively to voluntary participation in research, the obligation to minimize the risks and maximize the benefits for research participants, and fairness in the selection of participants. Of these, voluntary participation may be of particular relevance for human rights investigators. In academic research this is underpinned by the notion of informed consent – that a research subject voluntarily agrees to take part in research, in full knowledge of what this entails, and with the capacity and competence to make such a judgment.
The next set of ethical codes that I consulted took me back to the beginning of my own career in human rights. Journalism is not usually considered as particularly relevant in this context, but the declaration of principles of the International Federation of Journalists contains several useful pointers:

·       Respect for truth and the right of the public to truth;

·       Only report facts where the origin is known;

·       No suppression of information or falsification;

·       Use fair methods to obtain information;

·       Protect confidential sources.

Finally, another group that is not often considered in relation to human rights investigations: police officers. In fact, the process of accumulating evidence and reconstructing past events can be very similar and statutory human rights bodies may even have some of the same powers as police. As an example, the England and Wales College of Policing has an ethical code that contains a number of relevant provisions for human rights investigators, including, once again, protection of confidential information and non-discrimination and respect for equality.

For the purposes of my training event, I compiled a highly provisional nine-point list of principles that could constitute the basis for a code of conduct for human rights investigators:

      ·       Independence and impartiality;

·       Do no harm;

·       Protect safety and security of those affected by the investigation;

·       Informed consent to participation in the investigation (although this will not apply where an NHRI uses legal powers to compel the production of evidence);

·       Confidentiality;

·       Data protection;

·       Compliance with human rights standards;

·       Reliance on objective and verifiable facts;

·       Refusal to be influenced by threats or inducements.

What do readers think? Feedback would be very welcome, either in the form of a comment on this blog post or a direct communication (rcarver@brookes.ac.uk). I would particularly like to hear from NHRIs anywhere in the world that have experience of addressing these issues.

Monday, 9 October 2017

An end to refugee protection?


Richard Carver writes:

Two CENDEP scholars have contributed to a symposium in the Journal of Human Rights Practice looking at new challenges posed by the historically high level of forced migration in the world today. I co-edited the symposium, with Kirsten McConnachie from the University of Warwick and Martin Jones from the University of York, as well as writing an article on the role of national human rights institutions in refugee protection. CENDEP director Cathrine Brun, with Anita Fábos of Clark University, contributed a piece on new approaches to “durable solutions” for refugees and internally displaced persons.

The deliberately provocative title of the collection is “The end of refugee protection?” This is probably an instance of Betteridge’s law of headlines (which states that any headline that ends in a question mark can be answered by the word “No”). However, the implication is that the existing international refugee regime has been inadequate in the face of the multiple crises of the past few years. The common theme is not so much that refugee protection is at an end, as that there is a need to adopt innovative solutions. Cathrine and Anita, for example, point out the importance of bottom-up approaches based on refugees’ own needs and initiatives in a situation where protracted displacement has become the new normal.

It might seem unremarkable that a human rights journal should host a discussion on refugees, yet the sad reality is that the worlds of human rights and refugee protection are often far apart. The international legal regimes governing human rights and refugees were adopted at the same time (late 1940s and early 1950s), in response to the same set of events – the Second World War, Holocaust and subsequent refugee crisis. Yet the two sets of norms use completely different language and conceptual frameworks. The third legal framework updated at the same time, international humanitarian law (IHL), is different again. This would be all well and good if the aim were to generate work for international lawyers, but it can lead to crucial misunderstandings and efforts that are at cross-purposes. To give one simple example, the word “protection,” contained in the title of our feature, has quite distinct meanings in human rights, refugee law, and IHL.

One practical consequence of this has been that the communities of practice of human rights and refugee advocacy have often been quite distinct and separate. (There are, of course, important exceptions, such as Amnesty International, a human rights organization that has long worked on behalf of refugees.) My article in this symposium, in common with several others, argues for a new convergence between human rights and refugee protection.

Joint team from Greek and Macedonian Ombudsmen visit refugee border camp
The example I explore is a rare piece of good news to emerge from the European “refugee crisis.” National human rights institutions (NHRIs) – that is official human rights commissions or ombudsmen – have not historically done much work on refugees. This is because they are usually complaints-driven. Refugees tend not to be aware of the existence of such bodies or how to file complaints with them. In recent years, however, many European NHRIs have taken on a role in inspecting places of detention. This is usually because of a mandate given to them under the snappily titled Optional Protocol to the United Nations Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment – understandably referred to by its acronym, OPCAT.

The OPCAT requires that these “national preventive mechanisms” have legal powers to carry out visits to places of detention or imprisonment in order to inspect conditions and prevent torture or other ill-treatment. Among the places to be visited are immigration detention centres (and often, by extension, other migrant encampments, even if these are not formally places of detention). In this role, NHRIs, especially in southern Europe, have encountered refugees directly. The visiting bodies in countries such as Greece, Macedonia, Serbia, and Croatia have played an important role, not only in inspecting the conditions in which refugees are housed, but also in giving them advice and conducting more general advocacy on their behalf. International coordination between the inspection bodies has been aimed at creating a common response and making sure that refugees do not fall between the cracks of different national protection systems.