Showing posts with label settlements. Show all posts
Showing posts with label settlements. Show all posts

Friday, 5 October 2018

Charles Parrack presents shelter research at Global Shelter Cluster




At the Global Shelter Cluster annual conference in Geneva on 3-4 October Charles Parrack presented the chapter he co-authored with Professor Ian Davis on ‘The Long View of Shelter’, reviewing progress and changes in the shelter sector over the past 40 years. The chapter also discusses how lessons can be learned from disaster response from as long ago as the Lisbon earthquake in 1755, as well as more recent disasters such as the Haiti earthquake of 2010. The chapter is part of the inaugural publication of the State of Humanitarian Shelter and Settlements.
One of the main findings when reviewing shelter responses was that a separation continues to exist between emergency shelter response and permanent housing development. This reflects the division between the humanitarian sector, which focuses on short-term disaster relief, and the development sector, which works towards long-term recovery. Although efforts are under way to close this well-recognized gap, through initiatives such as the World Humanitarian Summit ‘Humanitarian - Development Nexus’ and the rise in prominence of the concept of resilience, progress remains slow.
Few humanitarian agencies possess an in-house technical capacity to create dwellings, or desire to become involved in permanent shelter and settlement, due largely to their restricted operational mandate, and time and financial constraints. For surviving households, the sheltering process from immediate protection to permanent housing is a continuous one. But for supporting agencies the process is usually fragmented into discrete phases (relief, recovery, reconstruction) due to budgets, capacities and timeframes. This fragmentation ultimately undermines longer-term recovery.
The consequences of shelter assistance are long lasting: settlements become housing, camps become temporary cities. The responses to some of the most significant disasters in history not only determined subsequent development patterns for the cities affected, but led to changes and developments that continue to influence housing and city design around the globe today. The 1666 Great Fire of London led to the first building regulations, while the 1755 Lisbon earthquake resulted in the world’s first urban plan designed to reduce the risks posed by earthquakes, tsunamis and urban fires.
Despite a wealth of evaluations, there has been little long term assessment of the harms and benefits of more recent shelter responses. The chapter calls for more initiatives in this area.

Tuesday, 23 January 2018

Work in Progress seminars - all welcome


This coming semester will see a new series of Work in Progress seminars at CENDEP, held at 4.30 every Thursday afternoon. We initiated the seminars last semester to provide a showcase for new research from CENDEP, as well as from our friends and collaborators. As the name implies, these are not necessarily completed research projects, but may be work that is still being developed, where the to-and-fro of an informal seminar discussion may be of help in taking it forwards.

The schedule is below – and includes a couple of films shown in collaboration with the Oxford Brookes Documentary Club and the Human Rights Festival. More news on the festival in coming weeks.


Monday, 16 October 2017

Shelter community of practice meets in Geneva

Each October in Geneva there is a gathering of the shelter community of practice. The Global Shelter Cluster invites cluster coordinators and shelter practitioners to come and discuss ongoing shelter operations and what we can learn from them, as well as to continue to discuss and develop strategy and policy on shelter after natural disaster and conflict. In the same week, Shelter Centre hosts a meeting to reflect on current issues for the sector, focused on international NGOs and research centres.

Charles leads a break out discussion on evidence at Shelter Centre meeting
Charles Parrack from CENDEP attended the Global Shelter Cluster meetings as part of Global Shelter Cluster working groups on Shelter Projects, State of Humanitarian Shelter and Settlements, and Promoting Safer Building, as well as the Environment Community of Practice. He also presented CENDEP research on safer self recovery at the Shelter Centre meeting.

One of the most important items to be discussed by the community of practice was the upcoming Sphere Project revisions. It is a great opportunity for the operational agencies to contribute to writing standards for shelter which, due to the adoption of Sphere by so many in the humanitarian system, will influence shelter practice globally.

The Shelter Projects working group has recently overseen publication of the latest volume of Shelter Projects, a compilation of shelter case studies that is becoming a very useful piece of the evidence needed to inform policy and practice. Charles has been influential in this project by working with the operational agencies to raise the quality of the evidence by introducing peer review and methodological rigour.

The State of Humanitarian Shelter and Settlements is an initiative of the Global Shelter Cluster to provide more detailed information and analysis on current shelter practice. It is at the start of the process currently.

Promoting Safer Building is a new working group focused on making sure that effective build back safer messages are identified swiftly for adoption by operational shelter clusters.


At the Shelter Centre meeting Charles presented CENDEP research on the scarcity of good evidence on safety in self recovery shelter programmes. He called for the community of practice to develop better evidence gathering practice, and to co-produce this research along with academic partners. He stated that research will not be successful unless both partners are involved. The practitioners have the depth of contextual knowledge, access and relationships with stakeholders, but time and capacity for research is scarce. Academics can ensure methodological rigour and analytical consistency.

Monday, 18 September 2017

A visit to Syrian refugee settlements in Lebanon


Abeer Al-Mutawakel (DEP 2016-17) writes:

In May 2017, I went on my first field trip with Oxford Brookes University to Lebanon. The field trip aimed to study the impact of displacement on Lebanon, particularly on the city of Saida and its surroundings, given the existing Palestinian and Syrian refugees in the country. Field trips are part of CENDEP’s program offered to students, which complement the academic side of research, and offer a practical side. During our stay in Saida we visited multiple Syrian refugee shelters and conducted many interviews. Visiting a shelter, and getting a chance to talk with people was a completely different experience compared to reading about it. Talking with Syrian refugees helped me to connect with them, feel their suffering, and learn about their journeys and the changes in their lives before and during the war in Syria. It made me feel the impact of a conflict in reality, and not just on paper.
Shheem informal camp
The first camp we visited was in Shheem. The camp has 380 people in it according to the Lebanese owner of the land who allowed them to stay there for free. They came from the different parts of Syria. They built their own shelters using donated materials. They were simple rooms, but Syrian women proudly referred to them as ‘my house’ when talking about them.

We all gathered in one place with the women in the camp for a group discussion. They welcomed us, offering us tea although we knew that they are short of basic commodities. During our gathering, the first noticeable thing was the care given to their looks, having make up on and nice outfits. It showed that women care about their appearance and dignity despite their hard living conditions.
Group discussion with women at Shheem camp
The second noticeable thing is the pregnancy rate among young women. Most young women in that camp were pregnant and had babies and toddlers at the same time. This concerned me about the opportunities for the coming generation.

During our group conversation, the Syrian women were open to discuss their situation, how their husbands are finding it hard to find jobs, and if they do, they are not paid fairly. They expressed their dissatisfaction about the relevance of aid being received both in terms of services (such as teaching them how to wash their hands or babies, which they found insulting) or in-kind contributions (such as clothes that do not fit their kids). This reflects the importance of understanding the context and conducting needs assessment, which was always emphasised on DEP students during multiple modules in its program.

Inside a house at Shheem camp
 

After our group discussion, I had a chance to have a side conversation with one of the refugee women who was one of the first comers to Shheem camp. She has been living there for six years. She has two girls and two boys. She invited me to her house; I was amazed how tidy and organised her house is, how she decorated the fridge and TV to make it feel like home for them. Although these are simple things, they made me feel her resilience and adaptability. Before leaving her house, she whispered to me excitedly that she has been offered to travel with her family to a foreign country, but did not know where yet. After six years in Shheem camp, she hopes that her and her family’s life will change. 

Pepsi shelter in Saida
We visited another shelter in Saida known as Pepsi. It was an old abandoned factory, which had three upper levels consisting of multiple apartments and two separated basements consisting of over 40 rooms for storage which were now all rented to Syrian refugees. There were 130 to 150 families living in this shelter with at least 800 kids. The interesting thing about this shelter is that all the refugees living in it are from the same town in Syria. When the war first started, families sent away youth between the age of 14-26 to avoid them being recruited by fighting groups, and youth later started calling for their families to come and join them. 

The basement rooms being rented in this shelter were not in proper liveable condition. Rooms looked like a garage and most of them did not have windows and therefore no air or sunlight. The basement was damp and dark.
Basement of Pepsi shelter
Some rooms would house a family of seven, and some even more (one of the rooms I visited was split into two, having the first wife and her five daughters in one half, and the other wife with her five kids in the other). Most rooms have a small kitchen built within the room and they all have shared toilets except for few. These conditions encourage the spread of diseases and impacts the growth of children living there. Some rooms are under the main road, and are at risk of having their ceiling collapse as happened with one of the rooms we visited. On top of these poor conditions, Syrian refugees pay rent of around $100 - $160 per room depending on the size. The apartments being rented in upper levels were much better and more expensive ($350/month).

Room in Pepsi shelter basement
A family we interviewed living in an apartment said that if they had a chance to live in the basement they would go for it, but they came late and there was no room for them, so they have to pay the higher rent. They can rent a better apartment outside the shelter with the same amount, but they’d rather stay with their ‘community’. Moreover, most kids living in shelters are not going to school. Parents worry about getting the basic needs such as food, shelter and health. In Pepsi shelter only a third of the children go to school and numbers keep dropping down because kids are expected to help in supporting their families.
Children pose for the camera in Pepsi shelter basement