Cathrine Brun writes:
I have just embarked
on a new project: With Oxford Brookes colleagues from Architecture and CENDEP
(Julia Wedel and Aparna Maladkar), Built Environment (Sue Brownill) and Social
Sciences (Maja Cederberg) I work on a university funded project on precarious
housing in the UK. This is a pilot project where we aim to understand what
precarious housing may mean and how we can best study the experience of precarious
housing.
In this context, I was
reading the brilliant book by Matthew Desmond, titled Evicted. It is a book that follows the intertwined stories of eight
families always in danger of being evicted: always on the edge, in debt, not
certain when and if they can pay the next rent. The book is set in Milwaukee,
US. When in danger of being evicted, precarious housing can be seen to have a
particular meaning. Susan Banki (2013) describes this condition as ‘not quite,
not yet’ and introduces the concept of ‘precarity of place’. Her work on
precarity of place concerns non-citizens, whose right to stay in a place
(nation state) is uncertain. However, in the work on housing, the understanding
of ‘precarity of place’ can, at a micro-scale, be transferred to tenure
security and the right to stay, have a home and dwell: the right not to be
physically removed. Housing precarity may then be understood as the not quite, not yet homeless.
In Desmond’s book Evicted, the constant danger of eviction
comes from being in chronic debt (mainly to the landlord). The challenge is
when more than 80% of your income may go towards rent, there is nothing left
for essential medication, food, and clothes for the children. There is a
race-dimension to it, and there is a gender dimension to it: More women than
men are evicted: women earn less, they have more difficulties in accessing
employment as a result of the requirement to care for dependent members of
their families.
The book’s personal
stories about eviction gives very strong testimony of dwelling in the temporary
and the challenges of creating a future, of moving on. They cannot establish
the stability that they may be longing for. People are unable to save. With
evictions their belongings may be forcibly put in storage if they have not
found another place to live and when they cannot pay the storage-rent, they
will lose all their belongings which restricts them in getting on with their
lives in a new dwelling. Without a permanent – or long term address – you may
miss out on letters about appointments to secure benefits and other assistance.
It becomes a vicious circle that is difficult to escape.
Desmond shows the consequences
at different levels. Evictions ruin everyday lives and neighbourhoods. When key
figures that maintain the social environment are evicted and forced to leave an
area to find even more precarious housing, the social glue disappears:
“For most residents
(…), the goal was to leave, not to plant roots and change things. Some
residents described themselves as ‘just passing through,’ even if they had been
passing through nearly all their life. One, an out-of-work father of three who
powered his trailer with stolen electricity, said, ‘We don’t let family come
here. It’s not us. It’s lower-class living, and I didn’t come from this.’ (…)
Tam, the pregnant drug addict, thought of the trailer park “as a hotel.” (Page
180)
People do not want to
stay in these conditions, they long for another life, their lives are on hold,
kept on hold because they are caught up in a crisis with little political
willingness to find solutions. Desmond shows that people are awaiting another
time: a time where they would move out of the just-surviving mode, but till
that happens they adjust to the situation. The families in Evicted spend all their time dealing with the consequences of the
bad quality, uncertain housing, unable to invest in the future for themselves
and their children, and being time-poor on a daily basis: when Arleen, one of
the protagonists in the book, calls more than 90 landlords to try to get a new
place to live and do not succeed, for example. She does not have time or energy
to deal with any other aspects of her life. She is caught in the housing
crisis.
Desmond shows that
poverty creates homelessness, but homelessness and evictions also create
further poverty. The housing situation in Milwaukee and US generally may not be
comparable to the situation in the UK. However, the organisation Shelter
estimates that a million families in the UK are threatened with evictions by
2020 due to a combination of low wages, freezes to benefits and costs of
renting (see Helm 2017). The not yet, not
quite homeless seems to be an expanding category, which will, if we are to
accept Desmond’s thesis, create further cycles of poverty.
References
Susan Banki. 2013.
Precarity of Place. A complement to the growing precariat literature. Global
Discourse 3(3-4): 450 – 463.
Matthew Desmond. 2016.
Evicted. Poverty and Profit in the
American City. Crown Books.
Toby Helm. 2017. Housing Crisis threatens a million families with eviction by 2020.
Guardian 24 June 2017, https://www.theguardian.com/society/2017/jun/24/social-housing-poverty-homeless-shelter-rent