Monday, 13 September 2021

Mindful Sheltering: how can the Shelter and Settlements sector recognise and enhance its impact on mental health in humanitarian crises?





Sue Webb and Emma Weinstein Sheffield write:

“Improved shelter conditions can save lives, reduce disease, increase the quality of people’s lives, help mitigate the impact of climate change ... and ... contribute to the achievement of the Sustainable Development Goals”


Recognition of the linkages between adequate housing and health has been gaining ground in high income and development settings in recent years and is now having an impact on humanitarian discourse and practice. Adequate housing for people displaced by disaster and conflict can help to protect them from respiratory borne infections like COVID-19 and mitigate other housing related risk factors for physical ill-health like household air pollution, overcrowding, thermal extremes and poor access to sanitation. Inadequate housing also impacts mental health both directly and through the stress related to physical ill-health. Inequalities in access to adequate housing and green spaces are particularly acute in humanitarian settings, where people living in overcrowded buildings and camps are at greater risk from a multitude of health issues, and have limited power to influence improvements to their living conditions. Awareness of these issues and related knowledge gaps prompted further investigation within the humanitarian Shelter and Settlements sector, responding to a need to uncover and better articulate the impacts of existing Shelter and Settlements practice on mental health and well-being and to plot a path towards more deliberate and documented beneficial impacts.


The Shelter and Mental Health Learning Event in May 2021, ‘Doing More and Doing Better’, explored the connections between living conditions, Shelter and Settlements activities and mental health. These three themes and the intersections between them, shown in the diagram below, were used as a scaffold for the agenda of the learning event and are reflected in the structure of the subsequent report, Mindful Sheltering, just published.


Mindful Sheltering reports on the online gathering of over 80 Shelter and Settlements, Health, WaSH, Protection and Mental Health and Psychosocial Support (MHPSS) practitioners and researchers that was instigated and hosted by the Centre for Development and Emergency Practice (CENDEP), Oxford Brookes University and CARE International UK, both partners in the Self-recovery from Humanitarian Crisis research team. The Global Shelter Cluster (GSC) has also awarded funding from the USA’s Bureau of Humanitarian Affairs (BHA) to CARE International UK to research the connections between shelter and health, which constitutes one of the priority issues agreed by the GSC Strategic Advisory Group in January 2021.


The GSC is the coordinating body of, and platform for, partner organisations delivering shelter humanitarian assistance worldwide. During 2020 GSC partners supported 15.5 million people with shelter and non-food items (NFI) assistance through 30 active country clusters. Increasingly, organisations and individuals working in the sector recognise that Shelter and Settlement responses not only provide and enable physical dwellings but also stable foundations to rebuild lives and support a range of multi-sectoral outcomes. One of these outcomes is health; people’s living environments have a significant impact on their physical and mental health, as shown in the diagram below.


In displacement settings, poor living conditions and tenure insecurity can negatively contribute to the compounding effects of trauma. There is also a link between physical health issues resulting from poor living conditions and mental stress. Unhealthy living environments disproportionately affect women, girls, the elderly and people living with disabilities, due to socio-economic inequities and these social groups often spending more time within the home. While the majority of people affected by crisis recover using their own resources, capabilities and networks, many need support from humanitarian and other external actors. The activities of Shelter and Settlements practitioners have the potential to improve people’s living conditions and in turn, people’s health and psychosocial well-being. 


Mindful Sheltering, available to download here, is a compilation of the presentations made at the event, from Shelter and Settlements researchers and practitioners and experts in Mental Health and Psychosocial Support (MHPSS) in emergencies, along with background literature and the key points and recommendations arising from discussion. Examples from many humanitarian and development contexts, including North-West Syria, Bangladesh, Nigeria and Vanuatu, were used to explore the connections between emergency and transitional shelter, housing and mental health. Case studies demonstrate that a person’s mental health and psychosocial well-being is affected as much - or even more - by their living conditions as it is by their experiences of crisis and disaster. Shelter is a determinant of mental health and well-being in all emergencies; inadequate shelter and poor access to water and sanitation facilities are among the ‘daily stressors’ that contribute to mental distress for individuals and communities and can be detrimental to early recovery and eventual development. 


The Shelter and Settlements sector can therefore promote good mental health and psychosocial well-being not only through the services it provides, but how it provides those services. Many aspects of ‘good shelter programming’ already contribute to mental health, such as routine inclusion of people with disabilities, including psychosocial disabilities, in programming. Shelter activities that aim to mitigate gender-based violence also protect and promote mental health, as do programmes that go beyond paying lip service to being participatory in design and implementation. Upgrades to people’s living conditions in post-disaster, conflict and protracted displacement settings can do much to promote both physical and mental health and support recovery. 


Mindful Sheltering contains recommendations to inform future Shelter and Settlements programming, advocating for holistic responses to ensure wide co-benefits of post-crisis rebuilding and recovery. Download Mindful Sheltering here to find out more. 





Webb, S., Foden, G., Weinstein Sheffield, E., Flinn, B., Cidón-Martínez, J., Solera-Mata, E. (2021) Adopting an Environmental Health Lens in Practice, Roadmap for Research, InterAction. https://www.interaction.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/Roadmap-for-Research_96ppi.pdf 


Weinstein Sheffield, E. and Webb, S. (2021) A Healthier Home is a Better Home Shelter Projects 8th Edition 


No comments:

Post a Comment