Monday, 15 June 2020

A right to consume? Resilience and climate change as human rights issues

Displaced family from South Sudan unable to reclaim their plot: the right to property can "unlock poverty traps" (UN photo)

EL Laskar writes: This year we had an opportunity to share reflections from CENDEP alumni. The voices of our alumni are important to us, they were the founders of the Oxford Human Rights Festival and their voices are part of the ongoing legacy of the festival. Our alumni make a rich tapestry across the globe and we welcome the voices, experience and expertise. Josh Ayers (CENDEP 2014) shared his reflections and highlighted some of the gaps of Article 17 of the Declaration of Human Rights - ‘Everyone has the right to own property alone as well as in association with others and no one shall be arbitrarily deprived of his property.’


The landmark 
Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) signed in Paris in 1948 began the work of codifying human dignity into a minimum set of rights that the majority of the world’s nations at the time could agree upon.  For decades, much of civil society has affirmed these by taking  “rights-based approaches” to works of justice and compassion, sustainable development and the alleviation of human suffering.  Faith-based actors have readily taken up this cause as well.  Our work at Food for the Hungry shares many of the hallmarks of a “rights-based approach," including a dogged commitment to the foundation of human rights - the dignity of the human person.  Based on this bedrock of human dignity, the preponderance of rights listed in the UDHR address issues of fairness, freedom, and equality, painting a picture of the ideal society that most today can agree on.  

So what does this mean for those of us engaged with issues of resilience and climate change?  Expressed as “rights” -  or moral or legal entitlements to possess something or act in a certain way - our rights-based approaches have a tendency to become individualistic, singularly and reflexively focused on the “I” and “you”.  I have a right to life, liberty, and the security of the human person (myself).[1]  I have a right to own property, therefore you cannot take it from me arbitrarily.[2]  De Soto’s influential work in The Mystery of Capital made the explicit link between ownership of property (and the legal recognition of that ownership) and the functioning of the capitalist economy.  It is the legal entitlement, or right, to own property that allows the owner of that property to do with it as he or she pleases.  It is indeed Article 17 of the UDHR – the right to own property – that unlocks poverty traps for many of today’s most vulnerable people.  


Ownership of property includes ownership of productive assets and raw materials that are often combined to provide livelihoods and income.  These productive assets themselves are manufactured using raw materials.  If we can just jumpstart vulnerable populations with the assets and raw materials needed, so the thinking goes, and link them with the formal financial institutions of emerging economies, their boats too will rise.  As such, with the right portfolio of assets and linkages with formal institutions, we could see unlimited progress. The assumption of unlimited progress, however, has come under increasing scrutiny from Kate Raworth[3], Tim Jackson[4], and others who argue that the natural resource base (e.g. timber, minerals, oil, soil fertility, etc.) upon which our current levels of production, consumption, and economic growth depend cannot support global poverty eradication.  To further the “rising tide” metaphor – even if there is enough raw material for everyone to have a boat (which is itself debatable at our current rate of consumption), there simply isn’t enough water to raise all boats at our current rate of resource evaporation. 

In a rapidly globalizing world, growing ever more interconnected and interdependent, the ways in which we each exercise our individual human rights becomes vitally important to our collective well-being or common good.  The right to own property is indisputable, though it naturally privileges those with the means to purchase. But what is our responsibility to others when we purchase, own, and expend natural capital that is finite?  Is natural capital truly finite?  Or is it indeed diminishing due to environmental exploitation, pollution, and a changing climate?  What impact do increasingly frequent natural hazards have on the natural resource base available to those most in need of it for disaster recovery and rehabilitation?  If we know that disasters disproportionately impact the most vulnerable among us, yet the natural resources they require for their own resilience are being bought up, owned, or destroyed by the wealthiest among us, the rights-based approach is arguably inadequate to address this rapidly deteriorating imbalance.  

Does the right to own property imply or presume a right to consume? 

What principles or moral ethic, other than the simple satisfaction of our own immediate individual needs by exercising our rights, can we call upon to address this tension?  Where is responsibility in the discussion of human rights?  Who has the social authority to promote and facilitate a moral ethic of ecological responsibility?  How might we awaken humanity to the possibility of denying ourselves and consuming responsibly for the common good?  Does the growing acknowledgement and recognition of the importance of local faith communities by the humanitarian industry offer an opportunity?  Is it time to revisit and take up the Universal Declaration of Human Responsibilities?


[1] United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Article 3. 
[2] Article 17. 
[3] Doughnut Economics: Seven Ways to Think Like a 21st-Century Economist (2018)
[4] Prosperity Without Growth: Economics for a Finite Planet (2009)

Josh Ayers is a CENDEP Alumnus and currently the Senior Risk & Resilience Advisor at Food for the Hungry.  He has substantial experience in project engineering and project management in the for-profit sector and in humanitarian relief, Disaster Risk Reduction (DRR), resilience, and Climate Change Adaptation (CCA). In addition to research on the role of local faith based communities in building social capital on the resilience of vulnerable communities in Myanmar as well as the socio-cultural aspects of resilience to occupation in the Middle East, Josh has significant experience with leading large, multi-disciplinary teams through research, design and implementation of complex projects that require integrated approaches to achieve outcomes related to topics ranging from conflict analysis, prevention, mitigation and peacebuilding, CCA, DRR, empowerment, needs assessment, poverty reduction, refugees, resilience, shelter, partnerships, and vulnerability and capacity assessment, analysis, design, implementation and M&E.

The OxHRF thanks Josh Ayers for his contribution.

No comments:

Post a Comment