Richard Carver writes:
A couple of years ago I was invited to submit a proposal to
the International Ombudsman Institute to write their official history, which would
be published to mark the institute’s fortieth anniversary in 2018. I submitted
my proposal, but my delight at being selected soon gave way to mild panic that
this might be the most tedious assignment I had ever undertaken. Forty years of
board minutes interspersed with a few reminiscing interviews: how could this be
anything but unutterably dull?
![]() |
| At the UN book launch |
I delivered my first draft late last year and this was the verdict of the IOI’s president, the
Irish Ombudsman Peter Tyndall: “I expected this book to be really
boring, but actually it isn’t.” Peter expresses the same sentiment, albeit a
little more politely, in his preface to the book, which was published last week. “Not as boring as expected” is hardly an endorsement to propel a work into the best-seller lists, but I really do know
what he means.
Why is the book not boring? First, digging in the archives
in Vienna, I uncovered a genuine financial scandal in the IOI’s history. My
next concern, of course, was whether the institute would allow me put details of this in the book, but I should not have worried. My work was conducted
under an editorial committee chaired by IOI vice-president Diane Welborn, which was highly
supportive and did not make any attempt to influence the content of my work.
Likewise, the secretariat in Vienna under Günther Kräuter facilitated my work with no attempt at
interference. The documentary evidence that I uncovered was then corroborated through
interviews with some of the key actors. And details of the scandal, which
nearly led to the IOI’s demise, are spelt out in the book. (No spoilers here –
you will have to read the book.)
While this was a dramatic episode in the IOI’s history, it
actually takes up no more than a few pages. More fundamentally, I would hope
that the book’s interest lies in the fact that it is an unvarnished and
critical view of the institute’s history. International relations scholars talk
about the importance of “transnationally networked policy experts,” especially
in the human rights field, and here they are in their natural habitat. The IOI
leadership has had the good sense to understand that much more can be learned
from an evaluation of mistakes and shortcomings, in order to place the (many)
achievements in their proper context.
For example, it has been an enormous struggle for the IOI to
become a genuinely diverse organization. For a long period throughout the
1980s, there were no women on the board. It was not until 2010 that the
institute had a president who was not a white man (Beverley Wakem of New
Zealand, followed in 2014 by John Walters of Namibia). In part this reflected
the world of ombudsman institutions that the IOI represents, yet the quest for
diversity was also the subject of much internal contestation for many years.
![]() |
| IOI 40th anniversary event at the UN |
Last week, at the United Nations in New York, Peter Tyndall
and Diane Welborn launched the book. In doing
so, they also tried to address a historic shortcoming of the IOI’s work, which
is the weakness of the IOI’s relationship with UN bodies. Since the 1990s, UN
human rights bodies have prioritized the work of national human rights
institutions and developed a close, formal relationship with the Global
Alliance of National Human Rights Institutions. The IOI, the only international
organization of public ombudsman offices, found itself left out in the cold for a long
time, despite the fact that many of its members double as human rights
institutions. Much progress has been
made in recent years, but a stronger alliance with the UN is a suitable and
realistic goal to be achieved before another 40 years have elapsed.
![]() |
| Bernard Frank |
The book begins with a discussion of the vision enunciated
by Bernard Frank. He was not an ombudsman, but a lawyer from Pennsylvania who
in the late 1960s developed a new perspective on the role of the ombudsman that was way
ahead of its time. In a period when the ombudsman scarcely existed outside the
Nordic countries, he argued that the institution could be a crucial human
rights actor. He was the main driver behind the establishment of the IOI, yet in
its early years few of its members shared Frank’s vision. By contrast, in the
latest version of its constitution, the IOI explicitly describes itself as a
human rights organization and now devotes much of its effort to defending
member institutions under attack from governments. Sadly, independent human rights defenders find themselves under increasing attack. History is not yet at an end.
A Mission for Justice:
The International Ombudsman Institute 1978-2018 is available from Verlag Österreich.




No comments:
Post a Comment