Richard Carver writes:
For an 87-year-old, George Soros has an extraordinary work
ethic. Not content with trying to stop Brexit, he is currently engaged in
secret manipulation of the survivors of the recent Florida school shooting and,
with fellow billionaires Michael Bloomberg and Tom Steyer, is working to bring about socialism in the United States. It may just be a coincidence that Soros
is a particular bugbear of Vladimir Putin, friend of Donald Trump, the National
Rifle Association and UKIP, but it is presumably not at all a coincidence that
he, like Bloomberg and Steyer, is Jewish.
But all of this is by way of a preface to what is truly the
nuttiest of all the anti-Soros claims, and one that is having a direct impact
on some very good friends of CENDEP’s. George Soros was born in Budapest. He
survived the war and Nazi occupation of Hungary by acquiring Christian identity
papers and then emigrated, first to Britain and then to the United States. Much
later, as a philanthropist, his own country of birth, still under Communist
rule, was a focus of his giving. One Hungarian beneficiary of Soros’s support was
a young democracy activist called Viktor Orbán, who received a scholarship to study at Oxford University.
Orbán is now, of course, prime minister of Hungary and, for
several years, has been fighting a high-profile battle to effectively destroy Soros’s
greatest contribution to post-Communist Hungary, the Central European University.
If you imagined that any national leader would be proud to host one of the
world’s premier academic institutions – well, you have much to learn about
Viktor Orbán. The Hungarian leader aspires to an “illiberal democracy” on the
Russian model. Membership of the European Union is some constraint on his
actions; Russia has banned the Open Society foundations but Orbán has to move
more stealthily (if not exactly subtly, as the illustrations below reveal).![]() |
| "Soros would resettle millions from Africa and the Middle East" |
All of which brings us to the latest attacks on Soros – and,
more importantly, on Hungarian civil society and refugees. In January, the government
published a package of laws under the heading “Stop Soros.” The claim behind this is that Soros was behind the flood of “illegal immigrants” into the country, with the intention of destroying Christian European civilization. (I
am honestly not making this up.) Of course, there is no flood of immigrants.
The large numbers of refugees who passed through Hungary in 2015 did just that –
pass through – and the fact that they came to Hungary had rather more to do
with the geography of central Europe than Soros’s ability to organize conflict
in Syria, Iraq and Afghanistan.
![]() |
"Don't let Soros have the last laugh" - implicit anti-Semitism supplemented
by explicit graffiti.
|
And this is where we come to our friends. The Hungarian
Helsinki Committee (HHC) will be one of the worst affected of civil society
organizations, as a consistent and highly effective advocate for refugees (and
a recipient of Soros funds). The Helsinki committees date back to the 1970s and
represent one of the best examples of citizen action in support of human
rights. Lisa Handley and I have worked as partners of the HHC since 2013.
First, members of the HHC conducted country research for our study of torture prevention and hosted our visit to Hungary in 2014. Then last year, Lisa
provided support for the HHC on a research project on prosecution of torturers,
and they hosted us again on a visit to study the use of immigration detention.
The response from the European Union so far has been weak.
While there is, rightly, a very high bar for EU entry when it comes to human
rights and the freedom of civil society, it appears that it never occurred to
anyone that there might be retrogression once a state was in the EU. Illiberal Poland
currently appears to Brussels as a bigger problem and, apparently, the EU can
only deal with one problem at a time (although the European Commission has
referred Hungary to the European Court of Justice). However, the Hungarian
Helsinki Committee (in concert with their Polish counterparts) has put forward
a very practical interim solution: the creation of an EU fund to support civil society
organizations. Such funding is normal for “third countries” (that is, non-EU members),
yet does not exist on a long-term basis for civil society within the EU. This
would be an essential lifeline to excellent organizations – and through them to
the refugees who desperately need representation and support.
The last word goes to Michel Forst, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights defenders: “There is a need for
European countries to be more coherent… not to teach human rights outside of
Europe and then not respecting human rights inside Europe.” Quite.
Full disclosure: I have knowingly been in the pay of George
Soros on at least three occasions – working for Human Rights Watch, ARTICLE 19,
and the Open Society Justice Initiative. I am clearly working for the Elders of
Zion and my views can be accordingly discounted.




Since I posted the above, the Financial Times has run an interesting piece on how the UK is wooing the Orban government to improve bilateral relations with Brexit impending.
ReplyDelete"Prime minister Viktor Orban is under fire from some western European countries, and from Brussels, for undermining the rule of law and extending economic favours to oligarchs and cronies. Mr Orban is a champion of what he calls “illiberal democracy”.
"Mrs May’s government is obviously aware of these trends. However, the priorities in UK-Hungarian relations are defence, security and trade. Foreign policy in the age of Brexit requires that, unlike other western European capitals, London must button its lip on Hungary’s domestic political conditions."
Both trade minister Greg Hands and foreign secretary Boris Johnson have visited Hungary in recent weeks and the British embassy in Budapest has expanded its staff. All this suggests that we in the UK may have a particular responsibility to make sure that our government doesn't continue to cover for Orban's attacks on civil society and refugees.
The FT article is here, but behind a paywall: https://www.ft.com/content/f26ac57e-22bb-11e8-ae48-60d3531b7d11
And this, for heaven's sake: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/foreign-secretary-in-hungary-to-celebrate-bilateral-ties
DeleteWhere did he get those shorts?