Friday, 29 April 2016

People smuggling – the case for evidence-based policy


Who are these evil people? Who is so bad that even David Cameron, a beneficiary of unregulated offshore activities, wants to “break their business model”? It is, of course, the people smugglers.

In part, this is the rhetoric of crisis. Social and political issues are very frequently expressed in the language of conflict. We have “wars” on drugs, crime, poverty, terror or any other perceived evil. (This is part of the same ill-considered metaphorical labelling that leads to the UK having an “inequality tsar.”) A “war on refugees” is a step too far even for Europe’s political leaders so we have instead a war on smuggling.

This war – the interception of boats carrying refugees across the Aegean – is of a piece with the deal between the European Union and Turkey to return refugees from Greece, an agreement that is both categorically illegal and destined to fail, even in its own terms. (Since the central element of the deal is that the EU will accept a refugee from Turkey for every one that is returned from Greece, it does not take an expert in game theory to work out that Turkey has no incentive to stop the smugglers’ boats from setting sail.)

However, the smugglers have been in the crosshairs – almost literally – for some time now. In 2014, Operation Mare Nostrum, a search and rescue operation run by the Italian navy, came to an end because no other EU state would support it. It was replaced by Operation Triton, with far broader support from European navies, but a much narrower remit of securing the EU’s borders. Not surprisingly, the death toll from the sinking of overcrowded and unseaworthy vessels increased rapidly.

In parallel, the EU set about launching a military operation, EUNAVFOR Med (rather more snappily known as Operation Sophia), to prevent vessels leaving the North African coast or to intercept them once they have. This entails the “boarding, search, seizure and diversion, on the high seas, of vessels suspected of being used for human smuggling or trafficking.”

There are a couple of points to note here. People smuggling is illegal under international law, which does give a mandate for Operation Sophia. However, the issue is not quite so simple, given that the operation also implicates human rights law (including the right to leave one’s own country) and law on the use of force (not to mention the law of the sea). It is far from clear that the EU navies can simply breeze around the southern Mediterranean boarding any shipping that arouses their suspicion.

Secondly, we should note the rhetorical subterfuge in the wording of Operation Sophia’s objectives. We are now presented not only with smugglers but with human traffickers. This same confusion of smugglers and traffickers has been a regular staple of media coverage of the Mediterranean crisis. For years we have been told about the evils of human trafficking, frequently labelled “modern slavery.” Traffickers are regarded as slave traders – by definition they coerce and transport people for the purposes of exploitation. In the relevant protocol to the Palermo Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime, exploitation is defined as:

the exploitation of the prostitution of others or other forms of sexual exploitation, forced labour or services, slavery or practices similar to slavery, servitude or the removal of organs…

Is that what is happening in the Mediterranean (or indeed the Aegean)? Of course not.

Rather, the confusion of trafficking and smuggling allows Europe to shift responsibility for the deaths of refugees to those who provide transport and away from where it belongs – with the governments that refuse to admit them and consider their claims (as required by international law).

There is, as it happens, a reasonable body of academic research on people smuggling, in the Mediterranean and elsewhere, and a good understanding of why the phenomenon has developed over the past quarter century. Smuggling in the Mediterranean is a direct consequence of the Schengen agreement. Freedom of movement within the Schengen area was accompanied by the creation of strict visa regimes externally. Legal (two-way) migration between North Africa and Europe was replaced by a new transport system that was capable of evading the border controls. You might even say that the smugglers’ “business model” was made in Brussels.

Some suggest that the business model includes the boats sinking and refugees dying. This is obviously nonsense. The continuation of the business depends upon capital assets – the boats. Smuggling is a completely unregulated transport industry (although one that advertises on Facebook and operates travel insurance). It continues to be profitable for the simple reason that refugees have been denied access to safe and regulated transport. Carrier liability and visa requirements prevent refugees from going to Istanbul Atatürk and boarding a Turkish Airlines flight to Frankfurt. Refugees seize the only opportunity our governments have left available to them. Research has established that restrictive entry requirements will only increase the resort to illegal means of immigration. European governments probably know this but windy rhetoric trumps evidence-based policy-making every time.

Richard Carver

No comments:

Post a Comment